As part of a deal to get Speaker Kevin McCarthy elected to the top House post, Tucker Carlson of Fox News received nearly 41,000 hours of January 6 video footage that was previously not made public. Carlson hyped the preparations for weeks, promising that the revelations would constitute bombshell reporting on Monday and Tuesday this week.
His commentary and selected video clips did confirm a few things that much of the conservative media had predicted. But if the idea was to neutralize the Democrats’ narrative about J6, the Tucker videos fell hopelessly short.
The Dems’ clever plan for nearly two years has been to peddle the false narrative that former President Trump directed the attack that caused a violent mob to deface the Capitol and disrupt official business to certify a new president. While Trump encouraged his supporters to march, he had asked them to do so peacefully. The certification of Biden was never in doubt – nor was it delayed – as Vice President Mike Pence duly presided over the largely ceremonious proceedings.
In due course, the House impeached Trump a second time, charging that he incited “the insurrection,” although an FBI report said that the attack had been planned two days before Trump’s speech. The Senate took up the articles of impeachment on February 9, 2021. It concluded with his acquittal on February 13, an outcome that was no surprise. The only penalty the Senate can hand down in impeachment proceedings is removal from office. Trump had already left office.
There was more to punish Trump and his 75 million voters. Twitter and Facebook banned Trump indefinitely, as did Instagram and YouTube. Parler, a conservative social media alternative to the legacy Twitter, got pulled from the Apple App Store and Google Play Store for not following the community standards of those two companies. Amazon Web Services dealt a fatal blow to Parler and refused to host the platform. Suddenly the Trump world had no public voice.
But the Dems were not yet done destroying a political rival. Under the excuse that Trump was a threat to democracy, they constituted a partisan committee to investigate what happened on J6, naming to the panel two Republican Trump haters, Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger, who had voted to impeach Trump. Using millions of tax dollars and primetime television, they used their subpoena power to commission a report that found Trump entirely at fault for triggering the events of January 6.
During two hours of his primetime show, Carlson had a unique opportunity to dispel several conclusions of the Dems’ J6 narrative. He could have asked why the protests even happened, reminding viewers that the outcome of the 2020 election was anecdotally doubtful. No American president in 180 years had failed to win re-election if he won more votes than in the first election. Trump had done extraordinarily well for someone who was so vilified. He won 11 million more votes than his 2016 count, for a total of 74 million. [In 2012, Obama handsomely won re-election although he earned 4 million fewer votes than his 2008 total]. A Fox News poll released in December 2020 found that 77 percent of Trump voters – some 56 million – thought the election had been stolen. Nearly every court that dismissed Trump’s post-election challenges relied on technical grounds but never examined the underlying election processes.
Tucker could have examined the various last-minute election laws the Democrats pushed through in 2020. We have pointed out numerous times in these columns that what changed in 2020 was the number of people who voted absentee in states that had little experience with no-excuse mail-in balloting. In states where the Left had no legislative control (Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Wisconsin), they filed over 145 lawsuits alleging that Covid shutdowns would disproportionately disenfranchise minorities and other communities of color. The remedies they sought were relaxed rules to accept late mail-in ballots and eliminating restrictions to verify ballot signatures against voter rolls. The J6 committee never looked at these issues. Tucker should have.
Tucker had access to so much video footage that if a person watched an hour of the material each day, it would take that person 112 years to finish viewing all the clips. Yet, even with a professional team combing over so much material quickly, he did not provide any evidence that disproved the Democratic narrative for two years. The J6 committee had done a clever job airing these violent moments in a loop – something the TV networks repeated for months. Tucker’s clips showing that most protesters were peaceful and walked around the Capitol as tourists do not nullify J6 video clips that showed violent protesters.
We are not apologists for those miscreants that stormed our Capitol. But we want to know why there continues to be so much discord about something as foundational as the conduct of elections in the world’s oldest democracy. America has had a peaceful transfer of power for the last 46 presidencies, including in 2021. But the two parties are never more divided about voting rights and integrity, with President Biden again throwing fuel on the voting rights fire in Selma last week.
Tucker could have used the J6 videos to educate the nation about this divide. The attack on the Capitol had never happened before, but it did. Hundreds of thousands of voters didn’t travel to Washington voluntarily and march to the Capitol just because Trump asked them to do so. They believed that something was wrong and were protesting over something more fundamental.
Tucker’s two shows were a missed opportunity. But, unlike the J6 committee’s primetime soap opera last summer with a defined end date, Tucker’s show is one of the most watched TV programs in media history. He still has several months to answer these questions for the nation’s benefit. America goes to the polls to elect our 47th president in just 20 months.
TIPP Picks
Issues & Insights Editorial Board
TIPP Staff
Daily Caller News Foundation
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics And Geoeconomics
#1. Russia’s Wagner Group losing Thousands: Infographics – tippinsights
Russia’s Wagner mercenary group is forced to use more professional soldiers in Ukraine to replace its depleted supply of enlisted prisoners, perishing by their thousands in the battle for Bakhmut.
To boost numbers, the group began to recruit Russian prisoners for frontline duty in exchange for a presidential pardon and a salary of 100,000 rubles. Being largely untrained and with poor discipline, these convict recruits have disproportionately borne the fatalities.
In February, Wagner ended its prison recruitment drive, partly due to word reaching prisoners about the high casualty rate.
Insightful Infographics, you won’t want to miss
#2. Volodymyr Zelensky Calls For “Democratic Success” In Georgia Amid Protests – AFP
Ukraine’s President Zelensky called for “democratic success” in Georgia, where protesters rallied against a controversial “foreign agent” bill reminiscent of Russian legislation to silence critics.
“There is no Ukrainian who would not wish success to our friendly Georgia. Democratic success. European success,” Zelensky said in his evening address to the nation.
#3. Georgia Withdraws ‘Foreign Agents’ Bill, Ruling Party Says – D.W.
The ruling Georgian Dream party said it was dropping a controversial bill on “foreign agents.”
The announcement came after two nights of violent protests and criticism that the draft law represented an authoritarian shift in the country.
The Georgian Dream party said it would “unconditionally withdraw the bill we supported without any reservations.” It cited the need to reduce confrontation in society.
The proposed bill, similar to laws in Russia, would have classified non-governmental organizations and media outlets as “foreign agents” if they received 20% of their funding from abroad.
#4. Russia Does Not Want Direct Military Conflict With U.S., NATO Forces: Intelligence Report – ANI
The U.S. intelligence community believes that Russia “probably does not want a direct military conflict with U.S. and NATO forces, but there is potential for that to occur.”
The assessment is according to the latest Annual Threat Assessment report of the intelligence community.
The report further stated that Russia would continue to use energy as a foreign policy tool to try to coerce cooperation and weaken Western unity on Ukraine.
Russia’s state-owned exporter Gazprom cut off gas to several European countries after they supported sanctions on Russia, contributing to soaring natural gas prices.
#5. Ukraine: EU Agrees To Start Joint Arms Procurement – D.W.
European Union countries agreed to speed up supplies of artillery rounds and buy more shells to help Ukraine but still have to work out how to turn these aims into reality.
Under a plan by foreign policy chief Josep Borrell, EU states would get financial incentives worth €1 billion ($1.06 billion) to send more artillery rounds to Ukraine. At the same time, another €1 billion would fund joint procurement of new shells.
Borrell’s plan would be a landmark step for the EU, as defense procurement has largely been the preserve of the bloc’s individual member governments.
#6. China’s Xi calls for ‘more quickly elevating’ armed forces – A.P.
China’s leader Xi Jinping has called for “more quickly elevating the armed forces to world-class standards” in a speech.
China must maximize its “national strategic capabilities” to “systematically upgrade the country’s overall strength to cope with strategic risks, safeguard strategic interests and realize strategic objectives,” Xi said.
His call came days after he warned the country was threatened by a U.S.-led campaign of “containment, encirclement and suppression of China.”
#7. Hunt For Oil And Gas Increases Risk Of Flashpoints In South China Sea, Report Says – RFA
A new report said that almost all the claimants in the South China Sea are proceeding with new oil and gas projects this year, heightening the risk of confrontations and even clashes in disputed waters.
The Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) report said that many of the new exploration projects lie inside the so-called nine-dash line that China uses to delineate its claims in the sea.
Six parties – Brunei, China, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Vietnam – hold overlapping claims over parts of the South China Sea. Still, China’s claims are by far the largest, nearly the entire area.
#8. U.S.-China Chip War: Netherlands Moves To Restrict Some Exports – BBC
The Dutch government says before the summer, it will restrict the country’s “most advanced” chip exports to protect its national security, following a similar move by the U.S.
It will include technology produced by computer chip equipment maker ASML. ASML is one of the most important global microchip supply chain firms.
In October, Washington announced that it would require licenses for companies exporting chips to China using U.S. tools or software, no matter where they are made worldwide.
The U.S. has been pushing the Netherlands and Japan to adopt similar restrictions.
#9. Australia To Buy As Many As Five Nuclear Subs From United States – Al Jazeera
Australia is expected to announce it will buy as many as five U.S. Virginia class nuclear-powered submarines in the 2030s as part of a landmark Pacific security pact with the U.S. and the U.K.
Under the so-called AUKUS agreement, at least one U.S. submarine will visit Australian ports in the coming years, and, by the late 2030s, a new class of submarines will be being built with UK designs and U.S. technology, one official said.
Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese will meet President Joe Biden and UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak in San Diego on Monday to reveal AUKUS’s next steps.
#10. UN Agency Calls For Probe As Iranian Students Protest Suspected ‘Poisonings’ – RFE/RL
The United Nations education and cultural agency UNESCO has called for an investigation into the suspected poisoning of schoolchildren in Iran.
Videos and photos published on social media show university students staging on-campus protests as the government’s slow response to the crisis fuels speculation over what could have caused more than 5,000 students, mainly girls, to have fallen ill.
#11. U.S.: North Korea Trying To Establish ‘Strategic Dominance’ Via Nukes – UPI
Kim Jong Un has no intention of abandoning his nuclear and long-range missile plans and is aiming to achieve “strategic dominance over South Korean and U.S. forces in the region,” U.S. intel report.
“[Kim] is continuing efforts to enhance North Korea’s nuclear and conventional capabilities targeting the United States and its allies, which will enable periodic aggressive actions to try to reshape the regional security environment in his favor,” the 2023 Annual Threat Assessment said.
#12. Taliban Is World’s Most Repressive Regime For Women, UN Says – RFE/RL
The Taliban has implemented the world’s most repressive regime for women, the United Nations mission to the country said in a statement to mark International Women’s Day on March 8.
It called on Afghanistan’s rulers to scrap the severe restrictions it imposed on its female population since returning to power.
The UN statement came as dozens of women staged a rare protest in Kabul, demanding more rights.
#13. U.N. Warns Of Aid Cuts Over Taliban Crackdown On Women’s Rights – Reuters
The U.N. envoy in Afghanistan warned that a Taliban administration crackdown on women’s rights will likely lead to a drop in aid and development funding in the country.
The United Nations has made its single-largest country aid appeal ever, asking for $4.6 billion in 2023 to deliver help in Afghanistan, where two-thirds of the population – some 28 million people – need it to survive, said Roza Otunbayeva.
Taliban administration bans women from attending high school and university, visiting parks, and working for aid groups. Women are also not allowed to leave home without a male relative and must cover their faces.
Republished with permission from TIPP Insights
