The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


Harris’s small business ‘opportunity economy’ plan = lemon socialism

by



Since Kamala Harris began releasing details of her “Opportunity Economy” plan, she has invariably talked about her small business initiative.

She has a point when she celebrates the contributions of small businesses to America.

The official definition of a small business is any enterprise that has fewer than 500 employees, although this number can vary by industry. Revenues should be restricted to $7.5 million annually (for sectors like retail and restaurants). However, a manufacturer can qualify to be classified as a small business even with revenues as high as $41.5 million annually.

The contributions of small businesses to America are so vast that they are worth repeating. Small businesses create about two-thirds of all new jobs, and because they recruit from within local communities, the employment is far more diverse. Small business owners have a keen sense of what products and services sell, so they lead in innovation. They are also inherently nimble businesses. If an item is not selling, they adapt it to meet customer tastes or retire it altogether. If our government at all levels – Federal, State, and Local – performed like the average small business, America would become the platinum standard of efficient capitalism.

Harris’s point is that each of us has a creative or organizational skill; why not monetize it by working for ourselves? It beats working for corporate America or the government.

To that end, Harris wants to set a goal of 25 million new small-business applications during her first term. For each new business, she would increase the tax deduction from about $5,000 a year under current federal law to a whopping $50,000.

The plan discriminates against current businesses. The obvious flaw is this: Why limit this “generous package” to only new small businesses?

A retail bank eager to attract a new customer may offer a $100 credit to their savings account, an offer not available to the bank’s existing customers. But how can government policy so openly discriminate against current small businesses, which are the engine of the economy? Small businesses pay heavily in taxes, so isn’t it ironic that current small businesses would be subsidizing new and inviting competition because of a government diktat?

It is clear that the Harris plan was quickly drawn up with the sweat of 20-year-something college graduates who know how to model a spreadsheet. Unlike the millions of small business owners she wants to help, Harris has never made a private payroll, and she appears to have no clue how her plan would impact America. Things always look fine on paper.

Tax deductions offer limited help to small businesses. Tax deductions and credits help large corporations, one of whose goals is to lower their tax burden and get the government to pay for investments they would have made anyway. Consider the often misused Research and Development tax credit, whereby companies can claim a percentage of their eligible R&D spending as a tax credit. But do these help a new small business other than being a giveaway to those who know how to work the system?

Every college student taking an accounting class knows the difference between tax deductions and tax credits. The former lowers a taxpayer’s total taxable income by the deduction amount (in the Harris plan, by $50,000), while a credit reduces the tax bill dollar for dollar by the amount of the credit.

Whether for a deduction or credit, the business detail we look at is taxable income, not revenue. The business counts the cash from the register each day, generated from the sale of goods or services. These receivables (cash, debit, and credit card receipts) are called revenue. The revenue has to pay for all the expenses of the business, including the inventory of the products sold, wages, rent, utilities, and marketing. The difference between revenue and expenses is the income. Federal, state, and local taxes are assessed on this income.

Most startup small businesses struggle to make a profit and fold down altogether if they can’t make ends meet. Even for those that make a profit, the income has to exceed $50,000 a year to get the full benefits of the Harris proposal.

Consider a neighborhood grocery store, a business where sector margins are about 2%. This store has to earn $2.5 million in revenue to have a net taxable income of $50,000. How many neighborhood grocers can boast $2.5 million in revenues?

Even if a new business manages to earn $50,000 in income, the net benefit is relatively meager. Suppose the owner is already in the 20% tax bracket. In that case, the effective monetary benefit from the Harris plan is 20% of $50,000, equalling $10,000.

Like many of her other statements, the Harris plan is a lot of hot air. It appears to be dramatic in scope and size, but when examined under the hood, it is a dud, making little positive economic impact. Most legitimate startup small business owners will derive minimal or no benefit from the plan.

But fraudsters will make hay. If history is any indication, the Harris plan will expend every dollar appropriated by Congress because there will be numerous startup small businesses that will magically spring up to take advantage of the financial incentives.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, various federal programs were established to support small businesses, such as the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) and Economic Injury Disaster Loans (EIDL). Unfortunately, these programs were susceptible to fraud, leading to significant abuses.

Many individuals submitted false information on loan applications, inflating the number of employees or misrepresenting business expenses to qualify for larger loans. Numerous cases of individuals creating fictitious businesses to apply for funds, often using stolen identities or personal information, were reported. Many recipients misappropriated the funds, using them for non-eligible expenses, such as personal expenses, rather than for payroll or other qualifying business costs.

According to the Small Business Administration (SBA), the estimated loss in the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) as of late 2023 was approximately $76 billion, representing around 10-15% of the total funds distributed.

More than 15 years ago, during the peak of the country’s financial crisis when the government bailed out the “Too-big-to-fail” banks, Paul Krugman, a Nobel Laureate in Economics, introduced the pejorative term “lemon socialism:” Taxpayers bear the cost if things go wrong, but stockholders and executives get the benefits if things go right. The term is just right for Harris’s “Opportunity Economy” plan.

Krugman is endorsing Harris for President and the lemon socialism inherent in her small business plan.

Rajkamal Rao is a columnist and a member of the tippinsights editorial board. He is an American entrepreneur and wrote the WorldView column for the Hindu BusinessLine, India’s second-largest financial newspaper, on the economy, politics, immigration, foreign affairs, and sports.

Your feedback is incredibly valuable to us. Could you please take a moment to grade the article here?

TIPP Picks

Selected by tippinsights

American Labor Activism – Infographic – TIPP Insights

Hurricane Helene Response Highlights Biden And Harris’ Failure To Lead – Brian Cavanaugh, The Daily Signal

Does This Country Need More Efficient Government? Connor O’Keeffe, Mises Institute

The Silly Peak Oil Debate Rages On – David Blackmon, DCNF

The Growing FOIA Backlog Undermines Government Transparency – Johnny Kampis, Issues & Insights

TIPP Takes

Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More

1. Deadly Israeli Strike On Central Beirut Kills At Least Six – Al Arabiya

Israel carried out a deadly air raid on a Hezbollah rescue facility in central Beirut, Lebanese sources said, after multiple Israeli ground troops were killed near the border.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

The second strike targeting the capital’s center this week follows Iran launching its largest missile attack yet on its arch-foe Israel, prompting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to warn Tehran would pay for its “big mistake.”


2. Biden Won’t Support A Strike On Iran Nuclear Sites As Israel Weighs Response To Iran Missile Attack – A.P.

“The answer is no,” Biden told reporters when asked if he would support such retaliation after Iran fired about 180 missiles at Israel on Tuesday.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Israel’s response choices range from a largely symbolic strike — similar to how Israel responded after Iran launched a barrage of missiles and attack drones in April — to hitting oil facilities and other infrastructure. Targeting Iran’s controversial nuclear program is seen as perhaps the most provocative action that Israel could take.


3. U.S. Warns Iran At UN: Don’t Target Us Or Israel – Reuters

“Our actions have been defensive in nature,” U.S. Ambassador to the UN Linda Thomas-Greenfield told the 15-member Security Council.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

“Let me be clear: The Iranian regime will be held responsible for its actions. And we strongly warn against Iran – or its proxies – taking actions against the United States, or further actions against Israel,” she said.


4. Israel Declares UN Chief ‘Persona Non Grata’ – D.W.

Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz has barred UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres from entering the country, accusing him of bias against Israel.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Katz declared Guterres “persona non grata” following what he described as the UN chief’s failure to specifically condemn Iran’s recent missile attack on Israel. Guterres issued a brief statement on Tuesday in which he condemned the conflict “with escalation after escalation” and referred to “the latest attacks in the Middle East.


5. Saudi Arabia’s FM Calls On World To Publicly Support Palestinian Statehood – Al Arabiya

“To the nations that have privately expressed their willingness to do this, I urge you to take this crucial step publicly. Now is the time to stand on the right side of history,” Saudi Arabia’s Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan wrote in an op-ed for the Financial Times.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

This comes just days after Prince Faisal announced the launch of a new international coalition to work towards implementing a two-state solution after decades of international efforts failed, leading the region to the brink of an all-out war.


U.S. and British authorities publicly linked an ex-Russian special forces officer to one of the world’s most notorious ransomware groups for the first time, adding further evidence of ties, formal and informal, between Russian intelligence agencies and criminal groups.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Eduard Bendersky, who served in the elite Vympel unit of the Federal Security Service, had been identified as early as 2019 as the father-in-law of Maksim Yakubets, the alleged founder of Evil Corp, whose malware has been used around the world to lock out corporate computer systems in exchange for ransom.


7. Ukraine Accuses Russia Of Executing 16 POWs – UPI

Prosecutor General Andriy Kostin of Ukraine said on X that the alleged execution occurred along the eastern front in Pokrovsk, Donetsk Oblast. The date of the incident was unclear.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

“This is the largest reported case of the execution of Ukrainian POWs on the frontline and yet another indication that the killing and torture of prisoners of war are not isolated incidents,” he said. “This is a deliberate policy of the Russian military and political leadership.”


8. Philippines Drops A Typhon Missile Gauntlet On China – Asia Times

In what could evolve into a Cuban-like missile crisis, Manila recently announced it would “indefinitely” host America’s state-of-the-art Typhon missile systems, a mid-range weapon the U.S. could bring to bear in any conflict with China over Taiwan.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Despite strong opposition from China and initial denials by Filipino officials, there are rising indications that the Philippine military intends to keep the much-vaunted American missile systems on its soil for the long term, or even “forever,” as military chief Romeo Brawner recently quipped.


9. U.S. Says Biggest Election Influence Threats Come From Russia, Iran, China – RFE/RL

The United States expects Russia, Iran, and China to continue their attempts to influence the November 5 elections by using artificial intelligence to disseminate fake information, according to a report released by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

The Justice Department last week provided examples of how Russia was behind a fake San Francisco television channel that spread lies about Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic party’s nominee for president.


10. Despite Constant Hovering By Chinese Ships, Malaysia Expands South China Sea Drilling – RFA

A U.S. think tank says Malaysia is broadening its search for new oil and gas clusters under its waters in the South China Sea despite China continually pushing to stop those activities with terse diplomacy and by dispatching hulking vessels to hover near drilling operations.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

But Beijing may step up the pressure as Malaysia’s state-owned exploration firm, Petronas, expands further afield within the country’s waters that China also claims, the Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) said in a published brief.


11. UK’s Keir Starmer In Brussels To ‘Make Brexit Work’ – D.W.

UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer met European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, on his first trip to Brussels as British premier.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Starmer said he wanted to “make Brexit work” for the British public and stabilize relations with the EU to boost the UK’s economic growth and security interests. But he had also long made clear he had no intention of pursuing more concrete steps like rejoining the Single Market or Customs Union.


12. CIA Seeks Informants In North Korea, Iran And China – BBC

On Wednesday, the CIA posted messages on its social media accounts in Mandarin, Farsi, and Korean, instructing users how to contact it securely.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

This latest effort follows a campaign to enlist Russians in the wake of the invasion of Ukraine, which the CIA says was a success. “We want to make sure individuals in other authoritarian regimes know that we’re open for business,” a CIA spokesman said in a statement.


13. American Labor Activism – TIPP Insights

Dockworkers who went on strike on October 1 are the latest union to echo demands for better contracts. At least 250 strikes and other labor actions have been recorded this year.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

14. Fizzy Drinks, Too Much Coffee Might Raise Risk Of Stroke – HealthDay News

The new research linked carbonated drinks – including those with sugar or artificial sweeteners – to a 22% higher risk of stroke. And, it added, risk rose sharply among those who drank two or more of these beverages a day.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

A study also found that a little coffee is OK, but stroke risk rose 37% after the fourth cup. The news was better for tea drinkers. Drinking three to four cups of black tea daily lowers stroke risk by 29%, while the same amount of green tea was linked to a 27% lower risk.


15. CDC Warns Against Potentially Counterfeit Meds Sold By Online Pharmacies – UPI Health

The search for more affordable medications might cause people to access dangerous counterfeit drugs sold as genuine products by online pharmacies, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warned.

Harris's Small Business 'Opportunity Economy' Plan = Lemon Socialism

Consumers who order pills from unregulated online pharmacies run the risk of ingesting potentially deadly fentanyl and methamphetamine. The National Association of Boards of Pharmacy says nearly 95% of websites that offer alleged prescription drugs are illegal operations that don’t follow the standards of state-licensed pharmacies.


📧
Letters to editor email: [email protected]
📰
Subscribe Today And Make A Difference. Consider supporting Independent Journalism by upgrading to a paid subscription or making a donation. Your support helps tippinsights thrive as a reader-supported publication. Contact us to discuss your research or polling needs.

Republished with permission from TIPP Insights

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *