The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!
The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


DAILY RUSH HOUR: China wants 100,000 young Americans. I have questions.

by

Hey folks—I know not everyone gets a chance to catch Rush Hour live, so I’m going to start including a link to each episode right here in the blast. That way, if you missed the show or just want to hear it again, it’s only a click away – or check out my thoughts below.

VIEW HERE: 

Look out for the Rush Hour link Tuesday – Saturday in your Daily BS email blast.

I heard something Thursday that made me stop. Chinese President Xi Jinping was standing at the White House, receiving all the ceremony that comes with a state visit — military honors, bands, flyovers, the works — when he announced what sounded like a wonderfully friendly idea.

China would like to invite 100,000 young Americans to visit over the next five years for exchanges and study.

One hundred thousand. My immediate reaction on the show was perhaps not sufficiently diplomatic: recruits? I’m sorry. Students.

Then somebody in the room offered another possibility: hostages? No, no, no. Students.

See, this is exactly why I probably won’t be invited to handle diplomatic relations with China.

But I don’t think I’m being unreasonable when I say that an invitation for 100,000 young Americans to spend time in China deserves a couple of follow-up questions.

Xi’s actual language was considerably more elegant. He talked about the history of Americans and Chinese fighting together during World War II. He said the future of relations between the countries lies with young people. Then came the invitation for 100,000 Americans to visit China for exchanges and study. Pasted text

And maybe plenty of young Americans will go there, learn something and come home with a better understanding of China. Fine. But let’s not pretend this is a field trip to Colonial Williamsburg.

This is China. This is the Chinese Communist Party. This is one of America’s most powerful competitors, and everybody at the White House understood that underneath all the handshakes and pageantry.

Xi himself acknowledged the competition. His message was that it should be “healthy,” kept within bounds and treated as a race in which the two countries catch up with one another rather than a wrestling match with a winner and loser.

Doesn’t that sound nice? Nobody wins, nobody loses, we’re all just running together.

Donald Trump had offered a rather different formulation at the United Nations when he talked about artificial intelligence and superintelligence. Somebody is going to win, and America intends for it to be America. Pasted text

That’s the real relationship underneath the state dinner china. Two enormously powerful countries can smile for the cameras and still understand that they are competing economically, technologically and strategically.

This is why I’m less interested in the language than the behavior. If China wants peaceful competition, wonderful. Let’s compete. If China wants young Americans to understand the Chinese people better, wonderful. But let’s also make sure those young Americans understand the Chinese government.

That’s not hostility. That’s adulthood. You can shake somebody’s hand without putting your wallet on the table.

The contrast became even more remarkable because Thursday’s other big international spectacle was happening in New York.

Benjamin Netanyahu walked into the United Nations and found a rather different reception. Delegates walked out. Protesters gathered outside. Susan Sarandon was among those arrested during protests over Netanyahu’s appearance.

Netanyahu didn’t seem particularly bothered. He went after the delegates who walked out, went after critics of Israel and then turned his attention to New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani.

“Shame on you,” Netanyahu said.

He accused Mamdani of distorting the facts about Israel, said Jews have told him they no longer feel safe in New York and attacked Mamdani over his associations and positions involving Israel and Hamas.

Then Netanyahu addressed Mamdani directly: “You tried to silence me. Well, you can’t silence me. You can’t silence the truth.” Pasted text

Whatever you think of Netanyahu or Mamdani, that is quite a scene: the Israeli prime minister comes to New York, stands at the United Nations and delivers a public dressing-down to the mayor of New York while protesters are outside and diplomats are walking out inside.

Rush used to compare the U.N. General Assembly to the Star Wars cantina. We talked about that earlier this week.

I’m beginning to think Rush was being unfair to the cantina. At least those people occasionally sat down and finished their drinks.

Meanwhile, back in Washington, Xi was talking about cooperation, Trump was hosting him with all the trappings of a state visit, and American television networks were still fighting with the White House over press access.

There were important things happening in the world: China, artificial intelligence, Israel, Iran, the Middle East, and the president of China standing at the White House offering to bring 100,000 young Americans to his country.

And an enormous amount of American television coverage remained focused on American television.

At some point you have to admire the consistency.

Thursday also gave us some music, thankfully. Nirvana’s Nevermind was released on this date in 1991. “Smells Like Teen Spirit” helped turn an album that initially entered the charts way down at No. 144 into one of the defining records of its generation. Pasted text

We also remembered Peter Byrne of Naked Eyes and “Always Something There to Remind Me.” Pasted text

That title felt particularly appropriate, because there is always something there to remind me that the words coming out of Washington, Beijing, New York and the United Nations matter considerably less if you don’t watch what the people saying them actually do.

Xi says America and China don’t need a winner and loser.

Fine. I’m still keeping score.

— Bo


Rush Hour airs Monday through Friday and moves quickly through the day’s hottest political stories, breaking developments and media absurdities. It is the fastest hour in American media because there is always more happening than the legacy media has time—or desire—to explain.

And if you want my daily stack of news and commentary delivered directly to you, sign up for The Daily BS here. It is free, arrives daily and, unlike a New York Democratic event, questions are not removed for exceeding ideological capacity.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *