The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!
The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


Mr. President, we can talk immigration. But citizenship? Hell no.

by

Donald Trump went on 60 Minutes and suggested that his administration might have been a little too tough when it came to deporting people who entered this country illegally.

The president who built an entire political movement around securing the border is now talking about working out a deal with Democrats to allow certain people to remain in America.

And on yesterday’s Rush Hour, I had a few things to say about that.

Now, before anybody starts accusing me of abandoning the president, let me explain something. I’ve supported Donald Trump through plenty of political battles. I’ve defended his accomplishments, criticized his Republican enemies and argued that his administration deserves credit where credit is due.

But supporting Donald Trump doesn’t mean I’m required to agree with every idea that comes out of Donald Trump’s mouth.

And this one deserves a serious discussion.

During his interview with Ross Douthat, Trump talked about people who have been living in America for years, working in hotels, landscaping businesses and other jobs, paying taxes and raising families.

He acknowledged that removing those people can be difficult and suggested that some sort of immigration agreement might be possible.

“I think it might be too tough,” Trump said about his administration’s deportation approach.

He went on to suggest that Democrats might be willing to work with him on a deal allowing some longtime immigrants to remain in the country.

Now, I understand the human side of this argument. I understand that somebody who has spent 15 years working, raising children and staying out of trouble isn’t the same as a violent criminal.

I get that. And I don’t have to abandon my conservative principles to recognize it.

But there’s another side to this conversation that Washington has an extraordinary talent for forgetting.

What about the people who followed the law?

What about the families who filled out the paperwork, paid the fees, waited for approval and did everything the United States government required of them?

What about the people who have been waiting years for their opportunity to come here legally?

Apparently, they’re supposed to watch while Washington figures out how to reward the people who skipped the line.

I have a problem with that.

And I made my position unmistakably clear on the show.

“I don’t want to see amnesty. I don’t want a deal that rewards people for being in the country illegally while other people try the legal access and are still waiting to get in.”

That’s the heart of it.

This isn’t about hating immigrants. America is a nation built by immigrants, and legal immigration has contributed enormously to this country’s success.

But a nation that refuses to distinguish between lawful immigration and unlawful entry is eventually going to have a difficult time explaining why anyone should follow its immigration laws.

And here’s where the fine print becomes important.

When politicians start talking about an immigration deal, I want to know exactly what they’re proposing.

Are we talking about allowing certain people to remain temporarily under strict conditions? Are we talking about permanent residency? Are we talking about a pathway to citizenship?

Because those are very different things.

I’m not saying there can never be any sort of arrangement for people who have been here for years without committing additional crimes. I said that on the show.

But I also explained the condition that would determine whether I could ever support such an agreement.

“You will never ever get a green card. You will never ever vote. You will never be a United States citizen, period.”

Now, that may sound harsh to some people.

But let’s consider what the alternative means.

If crossing the border illegally, remaining here long enough and avoiding additional criminal activity eventually puts you on the same path to citizenship as someone who obeyed the immigration laws, what incentive have we created?

We’ve effectively told the world that the rules matter right up until Washington decides they don’t.

And once again, the people who did things legally are left wondering why they bothered.

There’s another political reality here.

Republicans have spent years promising voters that the era of rewarding illegal immigration was over. Donald Trump made border security central to his political identity.

Those promises weren’t incidental. They were among the reasons people supported him.

Now, the president is entitled to reconsider the tactics of immigration enforcement. Any responsible leader should be willing to examine what’s working and what isn’t.

But reconsidering tactics is not the same as abandoning the principles behind the policy.

And I don’t want to see Republicans get themselves into another situation where they announce a compromise today and spend the next ten years pretending they never intended the consequences.

We’ve watched that movie before. The ending wasn’t particularly impressive.

Since the 60 Minutes interview, Trump has said there won’t be amnesty and that his immigration policy hasn’t changed.

Good. I’m glad to hear it.

But that still leaves the central question unanswered.

If a deal allows somebody to remain in America legally after entering illegally, what rights and opportunities does that person ultimately receive?

That’s where the discussion has to begin, not end.

Because I can imagine an arrangement that recognizes certain practical realities without handing out citizenship as a reward for breaking the law.

I cannot support a system that turns unlawful entry into a shortcut to the very benefits other immigrants have waited years to earn.

And if Democrats want to negotiate with President Trump, they should understand something else.

The American people aren’t stupid.

They know the difference between securing the border and simply announcing that certain violations won’t matter anymore.

They also know that politicians have a remarkable habit of calling something a compromise when what they really mean is that somebody else gets stuck with the consequences.

So, Mr. President, I’m willing to listen.

Tell us what the deal is. Tell us how it protects the integrity of legal immigration. Tell us why people who obeyed the law won’t be treated like fools for doing so.

And tell us, above all, whether citizenship is on the table.

Because on that question, I’m not interested in clever language, political spin or another promise that we’ll figure out the details later.

I have my answer already.

No.

— Bo

Look out for the Rush Hour link Tuesday – Saturday in your Daily BS email blast.