The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!
The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


Maybe it’s Maybelline. Maybe it’s another woke corporate makeover nobody asked for.

by

THE DAILY BS: HOW MUCH CAN YOU HANDLE?

SPARE ME THE BS (I’ve got things to do)

  • Maybelline has permanently changed its famous 35-year-old slogan, replacing “she’s” with “we’re” and breaking the familiar jingle into four short sentences.
  • The cosmetics giant says the revision celebrates inclusivity, confidence and “infinite possibility.” Global ambassador Miley Cyrus is fronting the campaign.
  • Beauty writers, marketing experts and customers are questioning why the company tampered with one of advertising’s most recognizable slogans. Some say the new punctuation looks like a typo.

LAY IT ON ME (I’ve got time)

For 35 years, Maybelline had one of the most recognizable slogans in advertising: “Maybe she’s born with it. Maybe it’s Maybelline.”

Millions of women knew it. The jingle practically sang itself. Naturally, somebody in a corporate conference room decided it needed fixing.

Meet the new version: “Maybe. We’re born with it. Maybe. It’s Maybelline.”

Yes, Maybelline has replaced “she’s” with “we’re” and added enough periods to make the sentence sound like it’s being read by a malfunctioning robot.

The company insists this isn’t just punctuation. It’s a philosophical breakthrough.

Maybelline global brand president Sandrine Jolly explained that the original slogan contained too much uncertainty. The new approach, she told Women’s Wear Daily, turns “maybe” into “a statement of possibility.”

The company says replacing “she’s” with “we’re” celebrates every woman’s confidence and freedom to express herself. The campaign, called The Beauty of Infinite Possibility, stars Miley Cyrus.

But here’s where the advertising experts started reaching for the aspirin.

Writing in Forbes, brand strategist Aliza Licht observed, “The ambiguity was the whole point.” She added that Maybelline had taken something familiar and given consumers a reason to criticize it.

Beauty editor Cristina Montemayor was even less impressed, describing the revised tagline as “a total disaster.”

And this wasn’t merely conservative commentators complaining about corporate political correctness. Allure, one of the beauty industry’s most recognizable publications, also criticized the change.

The magazine noted that Maybelline previously tried replacing the familiar slogan with “Make It Happen” in 2015, only to bring the original back. According to Allure, company research found that 84% of consumers still recognized the old phrase.

That’s the sort of brand recognition advertisers spend fortunes trying to achieve. Maybelline already had it.

The New York Post’s editorial board called the new campaign another example of corporate inclusivity messaging overwhelming perfectly good advertising.

Maybelline sees the change differently, arguing that modern beauty is increasingly about self-expression rather than simply looking attractive.

Fair enough. But apparently a woman can no longer be born with fabulous eyelashes without the entire marketing department being included in the experience.

The original slogan made people wonder whether a beautiful woman owed her looks to nature or makeup. The new one requires several paragraphs explaining why the word “maybe” suddenly needs its own sentence.

Maybe it’s progress. Maybe it’s a committee meeting that went on three hours too long.


DBS WIRE SOURCES