The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!
The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


White House silent on Israel’s massive NDAA windfall despite Trump’s aid cut pledge

by

Daily Caller News Foundation

The White House won’t say whether President Donald Trump plans to oppose congressional efforts to expand military cooperation with Israel despite his pledge to end American financial assistance to the country.

Congress is racing to finalize the roughly $1.15 trillion fiscal 2027 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) during the lame-duck session, with the annual military policy bill still awaiting Senate action after passing the House in July, according to the Congressional Research Service. The legislation is among Congress’s major year-end priorities ahead of a Dec. 11 government funding deadline and the arrival of a new Democratic-controlled Congress in January.

The Daily Caller News Foundation asked the White House whether it supports removing three hotly debated Israel-related provisions from the final NDAA, how their inclusion aligns with Trump’s promise to end assistance and whether the administration has discussed their removal with congressional leadership.

Trump announced on Nov. 3 that the United States would terminate approximately $4 billion in annual assistance to Israel by the end of the year, describing the financial arrangement as unnecessary during an appearance on “Fox & Friends,” according to the interview transcript.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu approached Trump months earlier about ending the assistance, the U.S. president said, adding that Israel could still purchase American weapons after the aid ends, according to the transcript.

The House-passed NDAA includes hundreds of millions of dollars for Israeli weapons programs, while the Senate’s version proposes expanding joint military research and manufacturing.

The White House has not clarified whether these expenditures would be affected by Trump’s promised aid cuts after multiple requests for comment.

Republicans’ sweeping defeat in the Nov. 3 midterm elections generated additional questions about the administration’s relationship with Israel, particularly after Vice President J.D. Vance publicly blamed the ongoing Iran War and American support for Israel for the party’s losses.

“The reason we lost is the war,” Vance wrote in a lengthy Nov. 4 X post.

Vance also cited inflation and a lack of focus on domestic priorities as concerns among disaffected Trump voters, according to his post.

A November poll found that 56% of registered voters opposed sending military aid to Israel, compared with 26% who supported it, according to YouGov. The survey sampled 3,166 registered voters from an opt-in panel between Nov. 4 and 6, weighted responses by demographic and political factors and had a margin of error of 2.2 percentage points, according to the pollster’s methodology.

Trump acknowledged growing public hostility toward Israel during a Nov. 8 interview with Ross Douthat on CBS’s “60 Minutes.”

“There’s a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel,” Trump said, adding that he didn’t disagree with Vance’s assessment, according to the transcript.

However, Trump defended the Iran strikes, claiming, “Israel would not exist except for Donald Trump,” according to the transcript.

Hundreds Of Millions Still On The Table

Congress has already proposed $750 million in U.S.-Israeli defense cooperation through the House-passed FY2027 NDAA, a $65 million increase over fiscal 2026, according to AIPAC.

The funding includes $500 million for missile defense, $100 million each for counter-drone and subterranean warfare programs, and $50 million for emerging technologies, according to the legislation.

The missile defense funding includes $300 million for Israeli Cooperative Programs, $150 million for Arrow 3, $20 million for Iron Dome and $30 million for short-range ballistic missile defense, according to the House bill.

The proposed $750 million would fund joint U.S.-Israeli weapons development and military technology programs, rather than simply providing cash assistance to Israel. Congress must separately appropriate the money before it can be spent.

The spending dispute also involves a much larger financial relationship between the countries.

The current U.S.-Israel military assistance agreement provides for $38 billion over 10 years, including $33 billion in military financing and $5 billion in missile defense cooperation from fiscal 2019 through 2028, subject to congressional appropriations, according to the Congressional Research Service.

Trump’s announced termination of assistance at the end of 2026 would therefore precede the expiration of the existing agreement. Congress retains authority over federal appropriations, meaning the president’s announcement alone does not determine the fate of every existing assistance program, according to the Congressional Research Service.

The House Armed Services Committee approved the NDAA in a 44-12 vote in June despite objections over spending and expanded cooperation with Israel, according to the committee. The House passed the bill 216-212 on July 22, according to the Congressional Research Service.

The bill is currently being debated in a House-Senate conference committee.

Deeper Ties

The financial provisions are only one component of the proposed expansion.

Congress has also advanced legislation that would formally expand cooperation between American and Israeli defense industries, including joint weapons development and access to emerging military technologies.

Section 219 of the House-passed NDAA directs the Secretary of War to designate an executive agent responsible for coordinating bilateral defense technology research, development, testing and industrial cooperation. The provision would facilitate joint ventures, licensing agreements and American-based manufacturing partnerships involving Israeli companies.

The arrangement encompasses artificial intelligence, autonomous weapons, electronic warfare, directed-energy systems, cyber defense, biotechnology and other advanced military capabilities, according to the House bill.

The Senate’s Section 1217 proposes a similar arrangement through the United States-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative.

The legislation could more closely intertwine the countries’ defense industries and make it increasingly difficult for Washington to separate American military interests from Israeli priorities.

“Section 224 [now Section 219] would mark a fundamental shift in U.S.-Israel defense cooperation,” Ben Freeman, the director of Democratizing Foreign Policy at the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft, previously told the DCNF. “In many areas, it would merge the U.S. and Israeli defense industrial bases.”

Opposition has extended across party lines.

Republican Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie and Democratic California Rep. Ro Khanna previously sought to remove the initiative, according to their proposed amendment. Khanna’s earlier attempt failed by voice vote, according to the committee.

“This is nothing more than codifying what has been happening for a long time,” Steven Bucci, a visiting fellow at the Heritage Foundation, previously told the DCNF. “This makes great sense.”

Such cooperation could continue benefiting American and Israeli defense firms despite Trump’s proposed aid cuts.

Twelve senators called for removing three NDAA provisions expanding military and intelligence cooperation with Israel in a Nov. 10 “dear colleague” letter, according to Democratic Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen’s office. The lawmakers targeted House Section 219, Senate Section 1217 and intelligence-sharing Section 618.

The intelligence provision would expand cooperation while restricting the administration’s ability to limit intelligence sharing without a national security justification, according to the Senate legislation.

The senators warned that the provisions could undermine U.S. independence, restrict Washington’s response to Israeli policies and shift military aid into less transparent defense contracts, according to their letter.

The letter was signed by Van Hollen and 11 other lawmakers, including Democratic Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, Democratic Washington Sen. Patty Murray, Democratic Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, Democratic Illinois Sen. Tammy Duckworth and Independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders.

The senators also pointed to Netanyahu’s expressed interest in replacing traditional American assistance with a broader defense partnership, questioning whether the proposed legislation could accomplish that objective without reducing Washington’s financial involvement.

The Senate letter also raised concerns about restrictions on the president’s discretion over intelligence sharing, particularly when the Israeli government’s actions conflict with American priorities.

The provisions remain under consideration as Congress reconciles the House and Senate NDAA proposals.

All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].

 

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *