The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!
The Daily BS • Bo Snerdley Cuts Through It!

Get my Daily BS twice-a-day news stack directly to your email.


Senate deal could leave future administrations a way to kill approved pipelines, conservatives warn

by

Daily Caller News Foundation

Heritage Foundation analysts say a future administration could use the permitting bill the Senate passed to pull approved pipeline permits over climate change.

The lame-duck Republican-controlled Senate voted 62-33 Thursday night to pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) — a permitting overhaul — and send it to the House. Two analysts at the conservative think tank warned the Daily Caller News Foundation that a Nov. 7 change allows agencies to go after approved projects over harm to “human health, the environment.”

“That sort of language could very easily be employed in the future to say, look, if you’re going to try to permit a natural gas pipeline, then we’re already in a situation where there’s immediate harm caused to the environment or to human health,” Heritage senior research fellow Jason Hayes told the DCNF in an interview Thursday before the vote.

“It’s not a big stretch to think that they would make that argument again in the future,” Hayes added.

Hayes pointed to Democrats who have tied wildfires and deaths to climate change. He said a future administration could make the same kind of argument against a natural gas pipeline.

The bill’s permit certainty section is supposed to keep agencies from yanking, pausing or materially changing a permit once a project with a non-federal sponsor has all its federal approvals, with a few exceptions. The manager’s amendment released Nov. 7 folded “human health, the environment” into one of those exceptions. That exception lets an agency step in to prevent “immediate, specific, urgent, substantial, and proximate harm or damage” based on new information, according to the amendment text the Senate adopted.

The same amendment added a separate exception for any action “taken pursuant to any applicable law or regulation.” Hayes wrote in a Nov. 17 Daily Signal op-ed that the second change “greatly empowers a future administration to evade the very permit certainty Congress is trying to create.”

Heritage policy analyst Sarah Wagoner told the DCNF the new health and environment wording is “definitely a risk.”

“It opens the door for different administrations to apply it differently, but it doesn’t inherently undercut all of the other reforms,” Wagoner said.

The Sept. 30 bill did not have the word “immediate” in that exception. It was added in the Nov. 7 rewrite, the bill texts show.

A spokesperson for Republican West Virginia Sen. Shelley Moore Capito — the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee chairman and one of the bill’s four negotiators — said in a statement to the DCNF that the added word means an agency could step in only to prevent immediate harm.

The spokesperson said the exception is there in case something goes wrong with a project and creates an immediate danger. Pipelines pose no such threat to health or the environment, the spokesperson said.

The offices of the other three negotiators, Democratic Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, Democratic New Mexico Sen. Martin Heinrich and Republican Utah Sen. Mike Lee, did not respond to requests for comment.

Hayes pointed to the Keystone XL pipeline as the kind of reversal he said permit certainty should prevent.

“Like if you get a permit and the next election it gets turned over, think Keystone XL pipeline,” Hayes told the DCNF.

Former President Joe Biden pulled Keystone XL’s presidential permit on his first day in office, according to his Jan. 20, 2021, executive order. TC Energy said it terminated the project that June after construction had been suspended following the revocation.

“So businesses are not going to invest, or at least they’re not going to invest in this country,” Hayes said.

Travis Fisher, director of energy and environmental policy studies at the libertarian Cato Institute, said in a statement Thursday night that projects have faced “years of regulatory delays, lawsuits, and the possibility of cancellation even after receiving federal approval.”

Fisher said in a statement to the DCNF on Friday that the bill’s language “strikes a balance between encouraging permit certainty, which is sorely needed, and allowing agencies to act in the event of a real crisis.”

“If [the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act] becomes law, the executive branch will lose the ability to revoke permits for nebulous or political reasons ranging from climate change to national security — there has to be a specific and urgent reason to revoke permits,” Fisher said.

Environmental groups have their own read of the clause. Earthjustice called the health and environment wording “a positive addition” in a review of the Nov. 7 changes written ahead of a Nov. 9 procedural vote.

The group argued the word “immediate” makes the exception harder to use and “would exclude, for example, authorizations for projects that elevate cancer risks.”

The group also wrote that the new catch-all exception “decreases certainty, promises extensive litigation, and fails to address the ‘forever permit’ problem that the original text created.”

The bill requires any action an agency takes under the health and environment exception to be “narrowly tailored in scope, duration, and degree,” and agencies must give permit holders written notice, the statutory authority they rely on and their evidence before acting, the amendment text states.

Hayes said the fix is to remove the language, and Wagoner noted the bill still has to clear the House.

“So obviously we like a lot of the things in the bill,” Wagoner said. “There’s a lot of wonderful things to support, but there are definitely ways to improve it.”

Fourteen Democrats and independent Maine Sen. Angus King joined 47 Republicans to pass the bill, while Republican Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley and Republican South Dakota Sen. Mike Rounds voted against it, according to the Senate roll call.

Backers of the bill want the House to move it quickly.

“This carefully negotiated package delivers reforms that have been championed by members of both parties and chambers for decades,” ClearPath Action CEO Jeremy Harrell said in a statement sent to the DCNF on Thursday night.

Republican Arkansas Rep. Bruce Westerman, the outgoing chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, told Bloomberg before the vote that he did not expect lawmakers to have time to change the bill before the current Congress ends.

“If the Senate gets it done then I think that’s what we’ll have to pass in the House,” Westerman said.

The Senate passed the text as a substitute to an unrelated House bill, H.R. 2347, its Congress.gov record shows.

All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].