BS BULLETIN:
-
Five-time WNBA MVP A’ja Wilson said her teenage self was focused on surviving the world, prompting a blistering response from OutKick’s Craig Carton.
-
Carton pointed to Wilson’s expensive private-school education and supportive family, accusing her of misrepresenting her upbringing.
-
He also revisited Wilson’s previous remarks about white privilege and fellow WNBA star Paige Bueckers.
A’ja Wilson just made WNBA history with her fifth MVP award. But an emotional comment about her teenage years has Craig Carton asking why one of basketball’s biggest stars seems reluctant to celebrate the advantages she actually had.
The Las Vegas Aces superstar became the first WNBA player to win three consecutive MVP awards Thursday. During her acceptance speech, Wilson reflected on her younger self:
“15-year-old A’ja wasn’t sitting up here dreaming about being a 5-time MVP. She wasn’t dreaming about being a 3-time champion. She was dreaming about surviving this world.”
Carton wasn’t buying the implication.
“It’s a bold-faced lie,” he declared on Friday’s Craig Carton Show.
His objection? Wilson attended Heathwood Hall Episcopal School, an expensive private school in Columbia, South Carolina. OutKick estimated that a student attending from first grade through graduation at today’s tuition rates would pay nearly $260,000.
Wilson was also raised by two involved parents, including a father who played professional basketball overseas.
Carton questioned why Wilson would describe her adolescence in terms that he interpreted as suggesting poverty or deprivation.
He argued that her family’s accomplishments should be a source of pride rather than something to downplay.
Then he turned to the subject of privilege.
Carton recalled Wilson’s previous comments about Paige Bueckers, in which she credited the young star’s talent but also suggested that understanding her white privilege helped her succeed.
Wilson had said Bueckers understood how privilege contributed to her opportunities.
“What about your privilege?” Carton demanded.
He also contrasted Wilson’s upbringing with that of WNBA player Sophie Cunningham, whose family, according to Carton, faced eviction during the 2008 financial crisis.
His argument was that Wilson’s own advantages deserve acknowledgment when she discusses those enjoyed by other players.
Carton suggested that Wilson was embracing a narrative of hardship rather than celebrating the opportunities her parents worked to provide.
There is, however, a distinction between Carton’s criticism and what Wilson actually said. Her speech did not explicitly claim she grew up poor, lacked parental support or lived in a dangerous neighborhood. Carton interpreted her reference to survival that way.
Wilson has not been shown responding directly to Carton’s latest criticism.
Her basketball accomplishments, meanwhile, are undisputed: five MVP awards, three straight MVP seasons and another year leading the league in scoring.
The argument now is over how she tells the story of getting there.
