It’s that time of year again, a time that many, if not most, Americans deeply dread: April 15, the U.S. federal income tax deadline. With that day now upon us, the I&I/TIPP Poll asked Americans whether they pay too much in federal taxes each year. The answer came back loud and very clear: Yes.

Specifically, the online national I&I/TIPP Poll of 1,432 voters asked the following question: “On the topic of taxes, do you consider the amount of federal income tax you pay as …”, followed by five possible answers: “Too high,” “about right,” “too low,” “don’t pay taxes,” and “not sure.” The poll, taken from April 3-5, has a +/-2.7 percentage point margin of error.

To anyone following today’s tax debate, the answers will come as little surprise: 56% of Americans believe they pay too much in taxes, while less than half (26%) say what they pay is “about right.” Only 3% say their taxes are too low, with another 7% saying they pay no taxes at all. And 9% say they aren’t sure.

So U.S. taxpayers are overwhelmingly convinced they pay too much in taxes. It isn’t even close.

While there are differences among groups, a majority of virtually all of the 36 demographic categories tallied each month in the I&I/TIPP Poll think they pay too much in taxes.

Not surprisingly, for instance, there’s a gap by income, though not as large as might be suspected. Among those earning under $30,000 a year, who pay less than 3% of their income in taxes, 47% still say they pay too much. That compares with 59% of those who earn $30,000-$50,000, 63% of those who earn $50,000-$75,000, and 62% of those who earn $75,000 or more.

In short, everyone thinks they’re overtaxed. That includes, by the way, a bipartisan consensus. Among Democrats, 50% say they’re overtaxed, while 65% of Republicans and 53% of independents agree.

We asked a follow-on question: “Please indicate if you think the following groups are paying their fair share in federal taxes, paying too much, or paying too little.” The choices included “lower-income people,” “middle-income people,” and “upper-income people” and “corporations.”

The responses were interesting, to say the least.

Just 24% said that lower-income people were paying their fair share of taxes, while 57% said they were paying too much. Another 8% said they were paying “too little,” while 12% weren’t sure.

The responses to “middle-income people” were fairly similar: 28% said they were paying their fair share, while 57% said they were paying too much and only 6% said they were paying too little.

The big shift in public sentiment comes with assessing how much in taxes are paid by upper-income Americans. Just 17% said they were paying their fair share, while an even smaller portion – 14% – said they were paying “too much.” But a whopping 60% said the higher-income folks were paying too little.  Not surprisingly, corporations elicited similar responses, consistent with the perception that they pay too little taxes.

Again, there was a surprising accord among both major political parties and independents on this issue. Among Democrats, 18% said the highest incomes were paying their fair share, compared to 21% of Republicans and 11% of independents. Another 11% of Democrats, 19% of Republicans, and 11% of independents said the upper-income folks were paying too much.

But 67% of Democrats, 49% of Republicans, and 63% of independent voters agreed that those in the upper reaches of the income brackets are “paying too little.”

Of course, the image of the wealthy getting even richer while paying no taxes, as the poor and middle class bear the burden is not exactly accurate. So the definition of “fair” needs to be considered.

The truth is, “fair” is entirely subjective. One person’s fair, is another’s unfair. But there are objective ways to gauge whether an argument over tax fairness is valid or not. It’s simple: What do people pay in taxes compared to others? And what did they pay before?

A look at the last couple of decades reveals a shocking result: “Tax cuts for the rich,” the supposed result of efforts to boost the economy through lower taxes, has in fact led to the wealthiest Americans paying the highest levels of taxes as a share of the total in history.

The latest data, which go through the 2021 tax year, tell the tale in a single image (from the nonpartisan Tax Foundation):

As the chart shows, the richest 1% among us now earn 26% of all income but pay more than 45% of all taxes, while the bottom 75% of all Americans earn 28% of all income but pay just under 11% of all taxes.

The chart also shows a recent steep rise in tax revenue from the wealthiest taxpayers. Why did this happen? Credit the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which is set to expire at the end of next year. If the law expires, it could be bad news.

“If the tax cuts are not extended, the U.S. economy will be hit by a $3.5 trillion tax increase, and most of the tax increase will fall on individual taxpayers and working families,” writes former assistant Treasury secretary and Merrill Lynch executive Bruce Thompson in RealClearMarkets.

Thompson adds:

According to the Joint Committee on Taxation, more than three-quarters of the individual tax cuts went to taxpayers earning less than $500,000 a year. Taxpayers earning under $100,000 will face an average tax increase of 16% a year.

Would that be tax unfairness? Or should those in the highest income brackets pay higher taxes no matter what, even if it leads to less tax income overall? Would that be fair?

As Americans this week ponder their hefty 2023 tax bills, and who’s paying what, they might want to know the truth that the I&I/TIPP Poll and IRS data reveal: That despite concerns over “fairness” and what President Joe Biden has called “tax giveaways,” tax cuts are sometimes the best way to boost the economy, lift wages, raise tax revenues, all while actually making taxes fairer.

I&I/TIPP publishes timely, unique, and informative data each month on topics of public interest. TIPP’s reputation for polling excellence comes from being the most accurate pollster for the past five presidential elections.

Terry Jones is an editor of Issues & Insights. His four decades of journalism experience include serving as national issues editor, economics editor, and editorial page editor for Investor’s Business Daily.

Want to dig deeper? Download crosstabs from our store for a small fee!

Our performance in 2020 for accuracy as rated by Washington Post:

1. Russia’s Putin Tells The Middle East To Pull Back From A Catastrophic Clash – Al Arabiya

Russian President Vladimir Putin urged all sides in the Middle East to refrain from action that would trigger a new confrontation, which he warned would be fraught with catastrophic consequences for the region, the Kremlin said.

Putin, who has forged much closer ties with the Islamic Republic since sending troops into Ukraine in 2022, spoke to Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi by phone about what the Kremlin called “retaliatory measures taken by Iran.”

2. Russia’s Meat Grinder Soldiers – 50,000 Confirmed Dead – BBC

Russia’s military death toll in Ukraine has now passed the 50,000 mark, the BBC can confirm.

The term meat grinder has been used to describe the way Moscow sends waves of soldiers forward relentlessly to try to wear down Ukrainian forces and expose their locations to Russian artillery.

The overall death toll – of more than 50,000 – is eight times higher than the only official public acknowledgment of fatality numbers ever given by Moscow in September 2022.

3. Russia To Grow Faster Than All Advanced Economies Says IMF – BBC

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) expects Russia to grow by 3.2% this year, significantly more than the UK, France, and Germany.

The IMF said oil exports have “held steady,” and government spending has “remained high,” contributing to growth.

Away from Russia, the IMF downgraded its forecasts across Europe. Economists at the IMF warned that if the Israel-Hamas conflict escalates further in the Middle East, it could lead to rising food and energy prices around the world.

4. Russian Crude Shipments Surge to the Highest in Almost a Year – Bloomberg

Russia’s seaborne crude exports soared to an 11-month high in the second week of April, with flows from all major ports near peak levels.

The jump in flows and higher Urals crude prices boosted Moscow’s oil earnings. The gross value of crude exports rose to $2.15 billion from $1.82 billion in the seven days to April 14.

5. China, U.S. Defense Chiefs Hold First Substantive Talks In Nearly 18 Months – Al Jazeera

United States Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin and his Chinese counterpart Dong Jun spoke via videoconference on Tuesday, the Pentagon said in a statement.

This is the first substantive talks in nearly 18 months as the two countries work to restore military ties.

An escalating diplomatic dispute and recent incidents between China and the Philippines, a U.S. treaty ally, at a disputed shoal have turned the strategically significant South China Sea into a potential flashpoint between Washington and Beijing.

6. China Is Funding The U.S. Fentanyl Crisis, House Panel Says In New Report – NBC News

The Chinese Communist Party uses tax rebates to subsidize the manufacturing and export of fentanyl materials, a House panel said in a report.

The House Select Committee on China pointed to findings indicating that China plays a key role in the flow of fentanyl into the U.S., and lawmakers made several recommendations to curb the crisis.

“Through subsidies, grants, and other incentives, the PRC harms Americans while enriching PRC companies,” the report says, referring to the People’s Republic of China.

7. China Axes Hundreds Of TV Dramas Depicting Family Tensions – RFA

China’s internet censors have deleted hundreds of online TV dramas for portraying the negative aspects of family life amid an attempt by the ruling Communist Party to get more people to start families and rescue plummeting birth rates.

Censors at video platforms Douyin and Kuaishou deleted more than 700 videos of TV micro-dramas portraying in-fighting between in-laws because of the “extreme emotions” they evoked, the government’s “Rumor-refuting platform” on Weibo reported.

8. China’s Spy Agency Encourages People To See Spies Everywhere – RFA

Analysts said that China’s top spy agency is cranking up its propaganda campaign warning of foreign “spies” to mark National Security Education Day to get more people to inform on each other and steer clear of anything linked to the West.

Introduced by Chinese President Xi Jinping in 2015, National Security Education Day is observed every April 15 to raise public awareness about safeguarding China’s national security, a core government interest.

9. Poland Plans to Join Europe’s Iron Dome-Like Air Defense Plan – Bloomberg

Prime Minister Donald Tusk said Poland plans to join a project to develop a European-wide air defense system to deter potential drone and missile attacks.

Tusk said Iran’s recent attack has confirmed the importance of having a system similar to Israel’s Iron Dome air defense. He added that Denmark has backed his plans to join the so-called European Sky Shield Initiative, which currently includes 21 countries.

10. EU To Begin Work On Expanding Sanctions Against Iran As Israeli War Cabinet Meets Again – RFE/RL

EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell says he will request that the EU’s diplomatic service start work on an expansion of sanctions in response to Tehran’s weekend attack on Israel.

Borrell commented on an emergency video conference of EU foreign ministers called to discuss the repercussions of the attack and as Israel’s war cabinet was set to meet again to decide its response to Iran’s weekend attack.

11. Iran Navy Escorting Iranian Commercial Ships To The Red Sea, Commander Says – Reuters

The move follows the first-ever direct Iranian attack on Israel, carried out in retaliation for a suspected Israeli strike on an Iranian diplomatic compound in Damascus.

Iran is bracing for a possible Israeli retaliation, with Israel’s war cabinet meeting on Wednesday to discuss a response.

“The Navy is carrying out a mission to escort Iranian commercial ships to the Red Sea, and our Jamaran frigate is present in the Gulf of Aden in this view,” Iran’s Naval Commander Shahram Irani said.

12. U.S. Says Russia’s Arms Trade With North Korea Violates Sanctions – Bloomberg

The U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, Linda Thomas-Greenfield, said Washington will seek ways to watch for violations after Moscow vetoed a measure to keep a monitoring panel alive.

During a visit to Seoul, the ambassador said the U.S. will work with partners such as South Korea and Japan to develop options both inside and outside the UN to maintain the work of a Security Council Panel of Experts—a sanctions watchdog on North Korea.

13. North Korea Has Capability To Genetically Engineer Biological Military Products: U.S. Report – Yonhap

An annual U.S. report titled “Adherence to and Compliance with Arms Control, Nonproliferation, and Disarmament Agreements and Commitments” noted that Pyongyang has a “dedicated, national-level offensive” biological weapons (BW) program.

In last year’s edition of the report, North Korea was described as having “at least a limited capability” to genetically engineer biological products. The change in the wording raised speculation that the North’s biological weapons production capability might have improved.

14. Rishi Sunak’s Plan To Phase-Out Smoking Among UK Youth Clears First Hurdle – AFP

A contentious bill that aims to eventually phase out smoking in Britain advanced in parliament, as the House of Commons voted to favor the controversial measure.

The bill would ban the selling of tobacco products to anyone born after January 1, 2009 –- effectively raising the smoking age by a year each year until it applies to the whole population.

Smoking is the UK’s biggest preventable killer, and opinion polls show that around two-thirds of people in the UK back a phased smoking ban.

15. Olympic Torch Relay Begins 3,100-Mile Journey From Greece To Paris – UPI

A symbolic lighting of the Olympic torch early Tuesday in Olympia, Greece, heralded the coming of the 2024 Paris Olympics this summer.

The ceremony was held at the stadium site where the Olympics first were held in 776 B.C. The choreographed ceremony marked the start of the traditional torch relay, during which runners carry the torch more than 3,100 miles this year to the site of the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris.

16. White House Announces Global Partnership To Prevent Future Pandemics – HealthDay News

The Biden Administration announced that it will work with 50 nations worldwide to try to prevent global pandemics such as COVID-19, which brought the world to a standstill four years ago.

As part of the initiative, the United States will offer support and expertise to nations, largely in Africa and Asia, to boost their preparedness, detection, and response to emerging outbreaks.

17. Controlling Blood Pressure Could Prevent Uterine Fibroids – HealthDay News

Middle-aged women tracked for up to 17 years in a new study were 37% less likely to develop these painful growths if they treated their high blood pressure with medication.

As outlined in the study, uterine fibroids are benign but painful tumors that arise in the uterus and affect up to 80% of women by the age of 50.

Women who treated their high blood pressure with one particular class of medications, called ACE inhibitors, experienced a 48% decline in their risk of developing fibroids, the team added.

Republished with permission from TIPP Insights